San Francisco · Sold

60 Santa Rita Avenue, Forest Hill: An Older Home with a Second Garden Lot

How Oliver Burgelman sold 60 Santa Rita Avenue in Forest Hill, an older home with a second lot used as its garden, and what the extra lot meant for buyers.

Oliver Burgelman Updated · 2 min read
60 Santa Rita Avenue in Forest Hill, San Francisco, with its garden lot beside the house, listed and sold by Oliver Burgelman

The property

Bedrooms
3
Baths
3
Lots
2

60 Santa Rita Avenue is an older home in Forest Hill, on one of the neighborhood’s winding, tree-lined streets. It came with a second lot next to the house, which the owners had used for years as their garden.

What buyers had to weigh

Buyers liked the property, and they especially liked the lot. A garden of that size is rare in San Francisco, even in Forest Hill.

The house, though, was an older home, and many of the buyers who loved the setting weren’t interested in taking on a big renovation. Some of them also didn’t want to pay for the extra lot. They liked having it, but it wasn’t something they had set out to buy.

How the sale ran

Buyers who loved the setting still had to weigh a renovation and the price of a lot they hadn’t planned to buy. That took some of the drive away from buyers to make offers, and the sale took a bit longer.

The result

In the end the property drew multiple offers, and it sold to a buyer who wanted the whole property: the house, the lot and the garden together.

What another homeowner can take from this

An extra lot, a large garden or another feature that sets a property apart will draw attention, but not every buyer will pay for it. When a home asks buyers to value something beyond the house itself, expect the right buyer to take a little longer to find, and plan the price and the timing with that in mind.

Photos

Living room with a fireplace and beamed ceiling at 60 Santa Rita Avenue, Forest Hill

Rear patio with a pergola and a lemon tree at 60 Santa Rita Avenue, Forest Hill

On Instagram

Behind the listings

Open houses, new sales and what I'm seeing on the ground in San Francisco and Marin, as it happens.

Follow @oliverburgelman